Skip to content
Why Believe

Tough Questions

What is the biggest difference between Catholics and Protestants?

Catholics and Protestants share the historic core of Christian faith: one God in three persons, Jesus as God's Son who died and rose again, the Bible as God's inspired word. The biggest difference is really about authority and how a person is made right with God.

Catholics believe final authority rests in Scripture together with sacred Tradition, interpreted through the Church's teaching office, led by the Pope. Most Protestants hold Scripture alone as the final authority above any church tradition or leader.

On salvation, Catholic teaching holds a person is justified through grace working together with faith, expressed especially through the sacraments. Most Protestants teach justification is by faith alone—a decisive declaration the moment someone trusts Christ, with good works following as evidence rather than a cause.

Both sides agree grace is essential, and both genuinely value good works. They disagree about exactly how grace, faith, and the sacraments fit together.

Bible quotations in these answers are generally taken from the Christian Standard Bible®, Copyright © 2017 by Holman Bible Publishers. Used by permission. Christian Standard Bible® and CSB® are federally registered trademarks of Holman Bible Publishers. Some biblical wording may be paraphrased or follow other translations.

Keep exploring with Why Believe

This answer is one of 250 questions in Why Believe — an app for taking an honest look at Christianity's hardest questions. It covers the evidence, the strongest objections and what Christians actually believe, with Deep Dives that go further into the reasoning, Scripture and sources behind each answer.

The app isn't publicly available yet — it's coming soon.

App Store · Coming soonGoogle Play · Coming soon
See the topics Why Believe covers